All Articles
Tool ComparisonsUpdated October 10, 202613 min read

The 12 Best AI Search Competitive Analysis Tools for 2026

Watching your own brand shows you the gap. Watching your rivals shows you who filled it. The twelve best AI search competitive analysis tools for 2026, priced from their own pages and ranked on how well they show the rival and the source behind each answer.

Matiss Katanenko

Matiss Katanenko

Co-founder, Honeyb

On this page
The 12 Best AI Search Competitive Analysis Tools for 2026

The best AI search competitive analysis tool for 2026 is Honeyb, because it shows every day which rival ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude or Perplexity names in your place and which source put it there, then recommends what to do about it. Profound, AthenaHQ, Peec AI and Similarweb also track rivals in AI answers. That matters because AI answers barely repeat themselves: SparkToro and Gumshoe found less than a one in 100 chance that two runs of the same prompt return the same brand list, so a competitor's lead only means something when a tool measures it again and again.

The argument of this guide is simple. Watching your own brand shows you the gap; watching your rivals shows you who filled it and what they used to do it, which is the only part you can act on. Below are the twelve tools that do that job best, each checked against its own website and pricing page. Honeyb is our own tool, so it is listed first, flagged throughout and held to the same tests as everyone else. If you want the wider category before you narrow down, start with the best AI visibility tools.

Why self-monitoring loses you the AI answer

When a buyer asks an AI model for a recommendation, the model returns a short list of brands. If you are watching only yourself, you see your own absence but not the name that replaced you, and you cannot see the source that put them there. The reason competitors win these slots is structural.

Reddit was the most-cited domain in Semrush's study of about 150,000 AI citations, and 62% of AI citations never name the brand behind them, according to Semrush's ghost citations study. Ahrefs found that AI visibility tracks third-party mentions and video more closely than anything on your own pages. Put those together and a model can recommend a rival off the back of a forum thread you have never read, which is why the rival's answers deserve as much attention as your own.

Top-pick change rate

How often the top recommendation changes between identical runs

How often the top recommendation changes between identical runs
ItemTop-pick change rate
Gemini44.1%
Perplexity42.5%
ChatGPT35%
Claude27.5%
Share of consecutive identical prompt runs where the engine's number-one recommended brand changed: Gemini 44%, Perplexity 43%, ChatGPT 35%, Claude 28%. Honeyb measurement: 20 buyer-intent prompts, 3 runs each, via API (gpt-5-mini, gemini-2.5-flash, claude-haiku-4-5, sonar).

The stakes rise as the answers take over the page. Pew Research Center found that Google users clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, against 15% when none did. When half as many buyers click through, the brands named inside the answer carry more of the decision, and so does whoever is named instead of you.

Sources also move quickly: Reddit's presence in ChatGPT answers fell from close to 60% of responses in early August 2025 to about 10% by mid-September (Semrush). A single reading is a snapshot, and a daily reading against named rivals is a trend. So the tools below are judged on three things: how deeply they track named competitors, whether they show the source behind each rival's mention, and whether they put you and your rivals in one side-by-side view.

How we picked and checked the 12 tools

A tool made the list only if it measures how AI answer engines treat competing brands (or, in one case, researches rivals well enough that buyers reach for it for this job) and describes itself plainly on its own site. Every price was read from the vendor's live pricing page, and every screenshot was captured from the vendor's public website. Otterly, Peec AI and Semrush show euros to a European connection, so their dollar prices come from US-served copies of the same pricing pages.

The 11 trackers side by side

ToolCompetitor trackingShows the source behind a rivalEntry price (as published)Free option
HoneybNamed rivals, daily, on every planYes, domain-level citations$23/mo billed annually, one engineFree start and free check
ProfoundNamed rivals, enterprise plansYesCustom Enterprise pricing7-day trial
AthenaHQWith an agent that acts on gapsYesFree tier; Starter $295/moFree Essential tier
Peec AISide-by-side competitor tableYes, gap analysis by domain$95/mo; Starter has 50 promptsFree trial
SimilarwebAI visibility next to web trafficYes, citation analysis$99/mo billed annually, or $129 monthlyFree trial
ScrunchCompetitor benchmarks per promptYes$250/mo (Core)Free trial
ZipTie.devUnlimited competitors, never billedYes, ranked by shareFrom $42.75/mo (usage-based)7-day trial, no card
Ahrefs Brand RadarAny brand across a 470M-prompt databaseYesBrand Radar AI from $199/moAhrefs Free account
Semrush AI VisibilityCompetitor Research reportYes$99/mo standalone toolkit (25 prompts)Free trial
SE VisibleCompetitors within an SEO-style trackerYes$99/mo, or $79/mo billed annually10-day trial
Otterly AIMe plus top competitors viewYes$29/mo; Lite has 15 promptsFree trial

Manus, a general research agent rather than a tracker, is reviewed at the end of the list for one-off competitor teardowns.

Want to get recommended by AI?

Check your AI search visibility, then let the Honeyb agent write, fix, and earn what gets you recommended. Free to start.

Free AI visibility checker

The 12 tools, reviewed

1. Honeyb (our tool)

Honeyb pricing page showing three plans with annual billing selected
Honeyb's pricing page with annual billing selected: The Minimum at $23 a month, Multi-Model at $63 and Full Spectrum at $159.

Honeyb, which we build, runs your prompt set every day and reports which competitors appear alongside you, how each one is described, and which domains the models cite for them. Every plan includes competitor tracking and source citation tracking, so a gap arrives with the page that caused it and a recommendation on what to do next.

  • Best for: teams that want rival-by-rival readings and a concrete next step at a published price.
  • Starting price: $23 a month billed annually ($276 a year) for 10 daily prompts on the engine you choose; Full Spectrum covers all eight engines, including Google AI Mode and AI Overviews, at $159 a month billed annually.
  • Strength: competitor tracking and domain-level citations on the cheapest plan, with recommendations attached.
  • Coverage: Full Spectrum tracks all eight engines daily, and Enterprise adds custom prompt volume, multi-market tracking and white-label reporting. Run the free AI visibility check to see your competitive picture first, or read how to measure your AI share of voice.

2. Profound

Profound pricing page with a free Trial and a custom Enterprise plan
Profound's pricing page: a free trial (50 prompts daily for seven days on ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews) and custom Enterprise terms.

Profound is an enterprise platform, backed by a $96M Series C at a $1B valuation in February 2026. It sells custom Enterprise plans to large brands, with SSO and SOC 2 compliance.

  • Best for: Fortune 500 teams with a procurement process and many competitors in many markets.
  • Starting price: custom Enterprise pricing after a free seven-day trial.
  • Strength: enterprise controls such as SSO and SOC 2.
  • Limit: no published price, and the trial stops after a week, so a smaller team cannot keep a competitive trend line running without a contract. Our Honeyb vs Profound comparison sets the two side by side.

3. AthenaHQ

AthenaHQ pricing page with Essential, Starter and Enterprise plans
AthenaHQ's pricing page: a free Essential tier with $25 of credit, Starter at $295 a month and custom Enterprise.

AthenaHQ treats competitor insight as the starting point for action: its free tier already includes sources and competitor insights, and the paid plans add an agent that proposes on-page and off-page fixes.

  • Best for: GEO teams that want the tool to suggest and draft the response to a rival's gain.
  • Starting price: free Essential tier; Starter at $295 a month on monthly billing.
  • Strength: an agent that drafts on-page and off-page responses, with integrations and CSV export.
  • Limit: usage runs on credits, and API access is a paid add-on, so heavy tracking costs more than the headline price.

4. Peec AI

Peec AI homepage showing its product illustration with a competitor table
Peec AI's homepage, whose product illustration shows a competitor table with visibility, sentiment and position.

Peec AI is built around a clean competitor view: visibility, sentiment and position for you and each rival, with gap analysis by domain and URL underneath. Over 3,000 brands and agencies use it, according to its site.

  • Best for: marketing teams that want a readable side-by-side view their colleagues will actually open.
  • Starting price: $95 a month; Starter includes 50 prompts on three models of your choice with daily tracking.
  • Strength: unlimited users on every plan, which suits teams that share the readout widely.
  • Limit: each paid plan tracks three models, and multi-country tracking starts on the Advanced plan.

5. Similarweb AI Search Intelligence

Similarweb AI Search Intelligence pricing page with three plans
Similarweb's AI Search Intelligence pricing: AEO Intelligence at $99 a month billed annually or $129 monthly.

Similarweb brings its web traffic data to AI search, so the visibility reading sits next to the AI traffic a rival actually receives. That pairing is useful when the question is whether a competitor's AI presence is turning into visits.

  • Best for: analysts who already benchmark rivals on web traffic and want AI answers in the same frame.
  • Starting price: $99 a month billed annually, or $129 month to month, for AEO Intelligence with 150 tracked prompts.
  • Strength: AI brand visibility, sentiment, citation analysis and AI traffic in one plan.
  • Limit: every self-serve tier includes a single user, and the competitive intelligence bundle costs $333 a month billed annually.

6. Scrunch

Scrunch pricing page with Core and Enterprise plans
Scrunch's pricing page: Core at $250 a month with 125 prompts on four engines, and Enterprise.

Scrunch organizes its analysis around the questions buyers ask and who wins them, and its Enterprise tier adds an Agent Experience Platform for serving AI agents a version of your site.

  • Best for: brands that want benchmarks today and an agent-ready site tomorrow.
  • Starting price: $250 a month for Core: 125 prompts, 5,000 responses a month, five user licenses.
  • Strength: a clear prompt-level benchmark against named competitors, with site audits included.
  • Limit: Core covers four engines (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and Copilot), so Gemini and Claude need Enterprise.

7. ZipTie.dev

ZipTie pricing page with a plan builder and presets
ZipTie's usage-based pricing builder: a Starter preset from $42.75 a month, with competitors never billed.

ZipTie prices by the check, and pointedly never bills for competitors, seats or projects, which makes it unusually cheap to add rivals to the watch list.

  • Best for: teams tracking many competitors on a modest set of prompts.
  • Starting price: usage-based, with a Starter preset from $42.75 a month; one prompt on one engine costs $0.01 a check.
  • Strength: shows which third-party platforms the engines cite, ranked by share and citation volume.
  • Limit: the bill moves with prompts times engines times cadence, so budget it before you scale.

8. Ahrefs Brand Radar

Ahrefs pricing page in US dollars with Lite, Standard and Advanced plans
Ahrefs pricing in US dollars: Lite at $129 a month, with 5 tracked AI prompts included.

Brand Radar lets you research any brand across Ahrefs' database of more than 470 million prompts, which means you can study a rival's AI footprint without setting up a single prompt of your own.

  • Best for: SEO teams already in Ahrefs who want to look up any competitor on demand.
  • Starting price: Brand Radar AI from $199 a month as a standalone tool; Ahrefs Lite at $129 a month includes 5 tracked AI prompts.
  • Strength: the prompt database answers competitor questions instantly, next to backlink and keyword data.
  • Limit: the tracked prompts bundled into base plans are few (5 on Lite, 20 on Advanced), so daily monitoring of your own buying questions costs extra.

9. Semrush AI Visibility

Semrush AI Visibility toolkit page with Competitor Research in the menu
Semrush's AI Visibility toolkit, with Visibility Overview, Competitor Research and Prompt Research in the menu.

Semrush folds AI visibility into its main plans, with a dedicated Competitor Research report, and it publishes much of the citation research quoted in this guide.

  • Best for: existing Semrush customers who want competitor AI data next to their SEO data.
  • Starting price: $99 a month per domain for the standalone toolkit with 25 prompts, or included from the Semrush One Starter plan (50 prompts tracked daily).
  • Strength: perception, narrative drivers and competitor research in the same login as keyword data.
  • Limit: you buy the SEO suite to get the AI toolkit, and the prompt allowance is modest until the Advanced plan (200 a day).

10. SE Visible (SE Ranking)

SE Visible pricing section with Basic, Core and Plus plans
SE Visible's pricing with annual billing selected: Basic at $79 a month (from $99 monthly), Core at $151 and Plus at $284.

SE Visible is SE Ranking's standalone AI visibility product.

  • Best for: SEO teams that want AI answers in a familiar SEO-style tracker.
  • Starting price: Basic at $99 a month, or $79 a month billed annually, with 200 prompts and three projects.
  • Strength: ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Mode, Perplexity and AI Overviews in one SEO-style report.
  • Limit: competitor analysis is solid but less opinionated than the specialist tools, with fewer recommendations on what to do next.

11. Otterly AI

Otterly AI homepage with a brand report illustration
Otterly AI's homepage, showing its G2 rating of 4.8/5 and Gartner Cool Vendor note above a brand report illustration.

Otterly offers a Me plus top-five-competitors view on its brand report and coverage of ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini and Copilot.

  • Best for: small teams that want a competitive read without a suite or a sales call.
  • Starting price: $29 a month for the Lite plan.
  • Strength: the Me plus top-five-competitors view, a 4.8 rating on G2 and a Gartner Cool Vendor listing in AI in Marketing.
  • Limit: 15 prompts is a thin sample for competitive work, given how much answers vary between runs.

12. Manus (for one-off competitor research)

Manus pricing page with three monthly plans
Manus pricing on monthly billing: $20, $40 and $200 a month.

Manus is a general AI agent, and many buyers searching for AI competitive analysis want exactly this: a research assistant that reads rivals' pricing, features and messaging and returns a comparison table or a SWOT.

  • Best for: a one-off competitor teardown before a launch or a pitch.
  • Starting price: $20 a month for 4,000 credits plus 300 daily refresh credits.
  • Strength: fast, structured reports on rivals' positioning from the open web.
  • Limit: it researches competitors; it does not sample ChatGPT, Gemini or Perplexity answers repeatedly, so it cannot tell you who the engines recommend over time.

Which tool fits your competitive question

Start from the question you need answered. If it is who the engines name instead of you, and why, Honeyb answers it daily on every plan, with the domains cited for each rival and a recommendation on what to do next; for an enterprise rollout, Honeyb Enterprise adds custom prompt volume, multi-market tracking and SSO. If you want to know whether a rival's AI presence turns into visits, Similarweb pairs AI answers with its web traffic data. If you already pay for Ahrefs, Semrush or SE Ranking, Honeyb runs alongside the suite. And if you need a single competitor teardown by Friday, a general research agent such as Manus is built for that one-off job.

Turn the gaps into a plan of attack

The dashboard matters only for the move it triggers, and a competitive analysis in AI search follows five steps:

  • Pick the questions. Choose the ten to twenty questions your best buyers actually ask, in their words.
  • Name the rivals. List the competitors you lose deals to, plus any brand the engines keep naming that you had not considered.
  • Sample repeatedly. Run the questions daily across the engines your buyers use, because one run proves very little.
  • Trace the sources. For every answer that names a rival instead of you, record the page cited for them.
  • Earn the place. Go after those pages: the Reddit threads, review roundups, comparison posts and videos the model is reading.

Because third-party mentions and video correlate with AI visibility more than on-page work (Ahrefs), the pattern usually points somewhere you can go and earn a mention. Start with the free AI visibility check to see who currently wins your category's answers, then decide where to close the gap first.

Sources cited in this report

sparktoro.compewresearch.orgfortune.com

Frequently asked questions

Is there a tool that shows competitors' AI search performance?

Yes. Honeyb, Profound, AthenaHQ, Peec AI, Similarweb, Scrunch, ZipTie, Ahrefs Brand Radar, Semrush, SE Visible and Otterly all show how often ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and other engines name your competitors, usually next to your own share. Ahrefs Brand Radar can also look up any brand in its database of more than 470 million prompts without any setup.

Which AI tool is best for competitor analysis?

Honeyb. It tracks which rivals AI engines recommend instead of you every day, on every plan, shows the domains cited for each one, and attaches a recommendation on what to do next, from $29 a month. Full Spectrum covers all eight engines, including Google AI Mode and AI Overviews.

What are the 5 steps of a competitive analysis in AI search?

Pick the buyer questions that matter, name the rivals you lose to, sample the answers repeatedly across engines, trace the source cited for each rival, then earn a place on those sources. The repetition step is the one people skip, and it matters most, because two runs of the same prompt rarely return the same brand list.

How often should I benchmark against competitors in AI search?

Daily if you can. Answers vary from run to run, and the sources behind them can swing within weeks. Only a continuous trend line tells you whether a competitor is genuinely gaining or you caught a noisy snapshot.

What is the difference between AI visibility monitoring and AI competitive analysis?

Monitoring answers whether an AI model mentions your brand. Competitive analysis answers which brands it names instead of or alongside you, how it describes them, and which sources put them there. Because 62% of AI citations never name the brand behind them (Semrush), the competitive view is often the only way to see who is winning the recommendation and why.

Can I check competitor visibility in AI search for free?

You can start for free. Honeyb offers a free check, AthenaHQ has a free Essential tier, Ahrefs includes a free account with Brand Radar, and Profound, Peec AI, Similarweb, Scrunch, ZipTie, SE Visible, Semrush and Otterly all offer trials. A free check shows who wins your category's answers today; a paid plan buys the daily trend line.

Matiss Katanenko

About the author

Matiss Katanenko

Co-founder, Honeyb

My name is Matiss Katanenko and I co-founded Honeyb, the agent that gets brands recommended by AI, tracking how ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and four more AI engines talk about them. Before Honeyb I ran SEO for fast-growing companies across the US and Europe, including one of America's 500 fastest-growing companies. The numbers I am proudest of: taking a site from zero to 200,000 monthly visitors in five months, and over $10M in client revenue attributed to organic search. I still run experiments across ten-plus of my own domains to test what actually works in SEO, programmatic SEO and AI search, and those experiments are what this blog reports on. My focus today is AI search visibility: how brands get retrieved, ranked and referenced by LLMs. I'm based in Riga, Latvia. In my free time I'm in the sauna, on a padel court, or behind a drum kit.

Free to start

Get recommended by AI search models.

Run a free AI search visibility check, then let the Honeyb agent do the work that gets you into the answers.

ChatGPTClaudeGeminiPerplexity